| 9 |
♡♡ |
Spicy Pumpkin Latte |
Highest value with good material cost |
| 8 |
♡♡♡ |
Pumpkin Spice Soda |
High value with good material cost. Can obtain 1 per day from Baku if he is visiting |
| 7 |
♡♡ |
Spooky Cake |
Good value with good material cost |
| 5 |
♡♡ |
Joke Soda |
Best option for early game |
| 5 |
♡ |
Jack-O-Lantern |
Cost is too high; recommended to save some pumpkins for cooking instead of only crafting these. Can obtain 1 per day from Berry if he is visiting |
| 4 |
♡ |
Pumpkin Pie |
Good option for early game |
| 4 |
♡ |
Pumpkin Pudding |
Good Option for early game |
| 2 |
♡ |
Pumpkin |
Basic starting option |
